February 2012
M T W T F S S
« Mar    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829  

An Interesting Test of the 10th Amendment

Up in Massachusetts, an interesting battle is being waged over the 10th Amendment and so-called “States’ Rights”.

Per this AJC article, here’s the basic story:

As some of you know, in 2004 Massachusetts became one of the first States to full-on legalize gay marriage. Under State law there, there is no legal difference whatsoever between a heterosexual marriage and a homosexual one. Obviously, religious groups in the State are free to adhere to different standards, except where they act as an employer.

The problem comes from the fact that there, as in Georgia, many of the citizens are employees of the Federal government – which, per the Defense of Marriage Act passed in the 90s, does not offer benefits to same sex couples.

Therefore, postal workers and other Federal employees cannot place their same-sex spouses on their benefits package, such as employer-provided insurance.

One such couple sued, and a US District Court Judge whose district apparently only encompasses Massachusetts has ruled in the couples favor that the DOMA “interferes with the right of a state to define marriage”.

That quote, in particular, is what makes this interesting politically regarding the 10th Amendment.
[Continue Reading]

Why I Want to Support Bobby Franklin But Can’t

State Rep Bobby Franklin is certainly an interesting case study in terms of political philosophy and political pragmatism/practicality.

Looking at just his pre-files for the 2010 session of the General Assembly that starts in about a month, he’s got several bills that are GREAT philosophically, though at least some of them are pure “mental masturbation” (ideas that are fun to debate, but stand little actual chance of happening) pragmatically. Then he’s got Ray McBerry’s “War Bills”. These are bills that, if enacted, would lead directly to a physical shooting war with the US Government – an idea he has said he supports.

Let’s take a brief look at the bills he has pre-filed this session:
[Continue Reading]

These Representatives Got Balls

I saw something while working on this post for Georgia Legislative Watch that caught my eye.

It was known as HR 280, and its title was “Claim sovereignty under Tenth Amendment of Constitution over certain powers; serve notice to federal government to cease and desist”.

Basically, this Resolution says that the 10th Amendment to the US Constitution declared that any power not specifically vested in the National government via the Constitution was reserved to the States. The National government was created to be an agent of the States, yet now treats the States as agents of the National government. Many National decisions are direct violations of the 10th Amendment, and SCOTUS ruled in 1992 that the US Congress can not simply override the legislative and regulatory processes of the States. Finally, there is a lot of stuff going on right now in Washington that if done as proposed would further violate the 10th Amendment.
[Continue reading]