Regulating Blogging

Apparently the Federal Trade Commission is pondering the idea of regulating bloggers.  Needless to say, this very concept is near and dear to the heart of SWGA Politics, and I’m a bit concerned with that this may entail.

At it’s heart, it looks basic enough.  They want to require bloggers who receive items or money to disclose such in their blogs since so many people these days look for product reviews and opinions from blogs (and we thank you by the way).  Since people do this, the FTC believes that they must step in and protect the consumer.  Gee thanks guys.  It’s just a shame folks are already doing it, ain’t it?

It’s true.  Most bloggers already disclose that they’ve received a product that they’re reviewer or endorsing.  They’re pretty open and honest about it, and then they go on to give a solid review most of the time.  The few who don’t are usually pretty easy to spot.  They all but scream their allegiance with no hint of a flaw in the product.  Readers spot this and bust them.  Once again, the market prevails.

And really, if this were where it would end, I’d probably not sweat it to much.  But it won’t.  You see, this is yet another assault on a blogger’s right to do what is right, or to be a shill for a company and lose all credibility.  Let the market handle the problem and let the government focus on what it does well, which is…um…I give up, what do they do well again?

Anyways, how long until an assault like this makes it to non-product blogs like this one.  How long until the Fairness Doctrine, for example, slams hard into blogs and requires Jeff and I to find a liberal and a conservative to balance our Libertarian perspectives?  Actually, we’d need two of each…just to be “fair”.  But how long until the Internet, the last truly libertarian region of the world, is as tightly regulated as the Soviet Union was?

People who are doing their research will find those blogs where the writer is just praising a product like it’s the best thing ever while not disclosing their bias is bound to happen.  It’s impossible to stop, and new regulations will be nearly impossible to enforce.  Instead, trust that those who are researching a product will get more than one opinion, and that the government has no business getting into regulating what bloggers say or don’t say.

With everything else going on in this nation, does the FTC have nothing better to do?

6 comments to Regulating Blogging

  • lunchcountersitin

    quote: “Most bloggers already disclose that they’ve received a product that they’re reviewer or endorsing. They’re pretty open and honest about it, and then they go on to give a solid review most of the time.”

    ?? Is this a personal observation, or is it based on empirical evidence?

    Myself, I believe in full disclosure of relationships between product reviewers and product makers. If there is a potential conflict of interest, I’d like to know.

  • Tom

    This is not just my observation but the observation of many others. They generally will tell you how they obtained the product. They especially will if they are trying to live up to journalistic standards. Full disclosure is usually given because potential conflicts are important, and their credibility as product reviewers can be destroyed pretty quickly should it be discovered that full disclosure wasn’t forthcoming.

  • SWGAPolitics.com in the Albany Herald on the front page below the fold—stop being modest, guys and hoot your own horn. And the article was by Jeff and Tom’s best friend in journalism, Carlton Flecher no less. Thanks for giving Sylvester’s ProjectLogicGa.com a “shout out.” Did SWGAPolitics put Peach Pundit squarely in their crosshairs? “Just what makes that little old ant, think he can move that rubber tree plant….”

    Congrats, Guy. And watch out Huffington Post.

    slyram’s last blog post..Memorial Day: Last Full Measure of Devotion

  • Tom

    Thanks man! We’re pretty stoked about the whole thing right now, and we seem to be getting a pretty good response as well. We may well post a little something about it later today ;)

  • MichaellaS

    tks for the effort you put in here I appreciate it!

  • [...] in May, I wrote about a potential move by the FTC to regulate blogging. The argument was that bloggers [...]

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>